President Ho Chi Minh appointed many non-party members as ministers; nowadays, there are none.

On September 2, 1945, President Ho Chi Minh read the Declaration of Independence, giving birth to the Democratic Republic of Vietnam. On that same day, the first government of an independent Vietnam—established by the Viet Minh—was announced under the name “Provisional Revolutionary Government of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam.”

1- The Provisional Revolutionary Government held its first session on September 3, 1945. This government consisted of 13 ministers and 2 government commissioners. Among the ministers, 8 were members of the Indochinese Communist Party, 5 were unaffiliated (non-party members), and 2 belonged to the Democratic Party. Ho Chi Minh served as the head of the government (President) while also holding the position of Minister of Foreign Affairs. The two ministers from the Democratic Party were Duong Duc Hien, Minister of Youth, and Vu Dinh Hoe, Minister of Education. Lawyer Vu Trong Khanh, who was unaffiliated, served as the Minister of Justice.

2- On January 1, 1946, the Provisional Coalition Government of Vietnam was formed, replacing the Provisional Revolutionary Government.

Ho Chi Minh remained the head of the government (President) and continued to serve as the Minister of Foreign Affairs.

This government comprised 15 ministers and one Minister of State. The Viet Minh (communist) faction held 7 ministerial posts, in addition to the presidency of the government. Duong Duc Hien (Democratic Party) remained Minister of Youth, and Vu Dinh Hoe (Democratic Party) remained Minister of Education. Vu Trong Khanh (unaffiliated) continued as Minister of Justice, while Nguyen Van To—also unaffiliated—served as the Minister of Social Relief. 3- On January 6, 1946, the first general election for the National Assembly took place. Nearly two months later, on March 2, 1946, the first session of the 1st National Assembly was held at the Hanoi Opera House. The National Assembly elected the Resistance Coalition Government, which replaced the Provisional Coalition Government.

The Resistance Coalition Government consisted of 12 ministers, only three of whom were affiliated with the Viet Minh; the others were either non-partisan or members of other political parties.

Ho Chi Minh (of the Viet Minh) served as President of the nation.

Huynh Thuc Khang—born in 1876, 14 years Ho Chi Minh’s senior, and a native of Quang Nam—served as Minister of the Interior (which encompassed the functions of the Ministry of Public Security). He held no party affiliation.

Lawyer Phan Anh—born in 1912, aged 34 at the time, and a native of Ha Tinh—served as Minister of National Defense. He held no party affiliation.

Lawyer Vu Dinh Hoe—born in 1912, aged 34, and a native of Hai Duong—served as Minister of Justice; he was a member of the Democratic Party.

Engineer Tran Dang Khoa—born in 1907, a native of Thua Thien, and a member of the Democratic Party—served as Minister of Transport and Public Works.

Former Emperor Bao Dai served as Supreme Advisor to the Government.

4- On November 3, 1946, the National Coalition Government of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam was established, replacing the Resistance Coalition Government.

This National Coalition Government comprised 12 ministers and 3 Ministers of State. In this government, only three individuals were affiliated with the Viet Minh: Ho Chi Minh served as the head of the government (President) while concurrently holding the position of Minister of Foreign Affairs. Võ Nguyên Giáp, a member of the Việt Minh, born in 1910 and a native of Quảng Bình, served as Minister of National Defense at the age of 36. Lê Văn Hiến, also of the Việt Minh, served as Minister of Finance.

Professor Hoàng Minh Giám, a member of the Socialist Party, served as Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs.

 

Huỳnh Thúc Kháng, who held no party affiliation, continued to serve as Minister of the Interior.

Professor Nguyễn Văn Huyên, a member of the Democratic Party—born in 1908 and a native of Hà Đông—served as Minister of Education.

Engineer Trần Đăng Khoa, of the Democratic Party, remained Minister of Communications.

Lawyer Vũ Đình Hòe, also of the Democratic Party, remained Minister of Justice.

Nguyễn Văn Tố, an educator with no party affiliation, served as a Minister of State (Minister without Portfolio).

Dr. Hoàng Tích Trí, who held no party affiliation—born in 1908 and a native of Từ Liêm, Hà Nội—served as Minister of Health.

Huỳnh Thúc Kháng also served as Acting President for four months—from May to September 1946—while Ho Chi Minh was in France at the invitation of the French government. Huỳnh Thúc Kháng fell ill and passed away in 1947.

Lawyer Phan Anh, who held no party affiliation, served as the first Minister of National Defense in Ho Chi Minh’s government in 1946. In 1947, he became Minister of the Economy. From 1954, he served as Minister of Industry and Trade, and subsequently as Minister of Foreign Trade, until his retirement in 1976 at the age of 64. In total, he served as a minister for 30 years. After stepping down as a government minister, lawyer Phan Anh served as Vice Chairman of the National Assembly and Vice Chairman of the Presidium of the Vietnam Fatherland Front. He passed away in 1990 in Hanoi.

 

Professor Nguyen Van Huyen, a member of the Democratic Party, earned a doctorate in the humanities in France in 1929, followed by a doctorate in law—also in France—in 1931. Ho Chi Minh invited him to serve as Minister of Education, a position he held for 29 years until his passing in 1975.

Phan Ke Toai—formerly the Governor-General (Tổng đốc) and Imperial Commissioner for Northern Vietnam under the government of the former Emperor Bao Dai—was invited by Ho Chi Minh to join the Viet Minh government. In 1947, following the death of Huynh Thuc Khang, President Ho Chi Minh appointed Phan Ke Toai to succeed him as Minister of the Interior. Subsequently, Phan Ke Toai served as Deputy Prime Minister from 1963 until his death in 1973.

Dr. Tran Duy Hung, born in 1912, was invited by Ho Chi Minh to serve as the Mayor of Hanoi, a role he assumed in 1945. An independent with no party affiliation, he became the longest-serving Mayor of Hanoi, holding the office for 23 years until his retirement in 1977 at the age of 65.

Following the death of President Ho Chi Minh in 1969… …no more ministers from outside the Communist Party were appointed.

Had Ho Chi Minh lived beyond 1975, he surely would have employed many officials from the former Saigon government. For in his view, the government belonged to the Vietnamese nation, not to the Communist Party of Vietnam. He believed that “anyone with talent should be invited by the government to take on the nation’s affairs.” He would undoubtedly have continued to appoint individuals from outside the Communist Party to ministerial positions, ensuring a unified state that represented a broad spectrum of the people from all walks of life.

On October 31, 1946, during the second session of the First National Assembly, Ho Chi Minh declared before the Assembly:

“I wish to declare before the National Assembly, before the nation, and before the world: I have only one Party—the Party of Vietnam.”

No other communist leader in the world would have dared to make such a distinctly “non-communist” statement.

Yet today, the successors within our Party do not follow Ho Chi Minh’s example, nor do they implement his ideology regarding personnel management. Nowadays, even a lowly department-level position requires one to be a Party member—a reality that has fueled the practice of “buying” offices and power.

In the past, those who passed the imperial examinations were appointed to official posts, regardless of their wealth or social standing. This ensured that talented individuals could step forward to serve the country.

Consider the case of Nguyen Hien: in 1247, at the age of just thirteen, he passed the examinations and was immediately appointed as a tutor to Emperor Tran. He later rose to the rank of *Thuong thu*—a position equivalent to that of a modern-day minister. That same year, 17-year-old Le Van Huu passed the imperial examination and was appointed to an official post, eventually rising to the position of Minister of War—the equivalent of today’s Minister of National Defense. Beyond his official duties, Le Van Huu dedicated himself to writing history, becoming one of Vietnam’s greatest historians.

Today, securing an appointment often requires bribery, sycophancy, and currying favor. Consequently, under the Party’s regime, there has never been such an abundance of opportunistic, self-serving individuals achieving success.

In the past, the scholar Chu Van An dared to resign—symbolically hanging up his official cap and robe—to protest the imperial court’s reliance on sycophants. Today, while opportunists and flatterers are everywhere, not a single official has the integrity to resign in protest. The moral caliber of the Party’s current administrative apparatus is beyond abysmal—far more corrupt and rotten than in the times of our ancestors.

Nowadays, the younger generation within the Party claims to “follow the Thought of Ho Chi Minh,” yet they do nothing of the sort.

It is all just empty talk.///

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *